Pete Evans' documentary should be cut from Netflix, doctors group says
Australia news Pete Evans' documentary should be cut from Netflix, doctors group says
AMA says celebrity chefâs film claiming ketogenic diet can help serious medical conditions is âirresponsibleâ
The Australian Medical Association has called on Netflix to remove an âirresponsibleâ documentary from celebrity chef Pe te Evans that claims diet can help autism, asthma and even cancer.
The Magic Pill, a 2017 film produced and narrated by Evans, advocates for the ketogenic diet â" one that is extremely low in carbohydrates, but high in fat and protein.
One case study from the film said the diet had helped a young child deal with autism, after five weeks of avoiding carbs. Another claimed that a womanâs breast cancer tumour shrunk.
Dr Tony Bartone, the head of the AMA, said this portrayal of a ketogenic diet as a cure-all could have harmful effects, especially on cancer patients and children.
âThere is some early evidence, and lot of animal models, that it may have a role in maybe autism, certainly epilepsy â" but it is still yet to be fully evaluated,â he said.
âA ketogenic diet is not without risk and it really should be performed in conjunction with a medical practitioner. A long term ketogenic diet can be associated with unhealthy weight loss, kidne y stones, and in children can lead to nutritional deficiencies and immune system issues.â
The ketogenic diet, as set out in the film, tells viewers to eat whole and organic foods, avoid grains and dairy, eat a high level of animal fats, olive oil, eggs and avocados, and avoid âbad fatsâ like vegetable oils.
In 2015, one of Evansâs cookbooks for children was pulled from publication after a recipe was dis covered to be potentially fatal for babies. His recipe for DIY milk formula, made from liver and bone broth, had 10 times the safe limit of vitamin A.
Last year, Evans was also criticised by the AMA for claiming dairy removed calcium from bones and that sunscreen was toxic.
Bartone said The Magic Pillâs claims around cancer were especially harmful.
âThis is trying to work on the vulnerable and the impressionable in our community. They should be listening to their oncologist or medical practitioner and not a celebrity chef.â
Evans responded to the claims on Facebook, saying the medical association had an interest in keeping Australians unhealthy.
âDoes the head of the AMA believe that eating vegetables and fruit with a side of well sourced meat/seafood/eggs to be a dangerous way of life? Perhaps the bigger question to ask would be, âIs the head of the AMA fearful of people in Australia becoming healthy? What would this mean to their industry?ââ
The chef claimed his film was backed up by leading cardiologists, doctors and scientists.
âModern medicine is fabulous and vitally needed as we do say in the film, however, when 70-80% of illness is diet/lifestyle related, then shouldnât prevention be a considered approach?â
The film also begins with a disclaimer that tells viewers that apart from food, factors like exercise, sleep and meditation play a role in overall health as well.
âWhile we emphasise the science behind the dietary advice, the personal stories portrayed in this film are anecdotal and we make no claims that these experiences are typical,â it says. âAlways consult with you doctor or health professional before starting any new diet.â
This is then followed by a quote attributed to ancient Greek physician Hippocrates that ânature is the healer of diseaseâ.Topics
- Australia news
- Share on Faceboo k
- Share on Twitter
- Share via Email
- Share on LinkedIn
- Share on Pinterest
- Share on Google+
- Share on WhatsApp
- Share on Messenger
- Reuse this content